The classical view of the incarnation teaches that jesus maintained all of his divine attributes. Stephen evans defends as religiously powerful and theologically legitimate, a kenotic theory of the incarnation, arguing that some kind of divine self. Although the main thrust of the kenotic theory led into some barren speculation, it is well to note positive contributions which the theory has made to the doctrine of the incarnation. The term kenosis refers to the doctrine of christs selfemptying in his incarnation. We should withhold our reservations, however, until we. Exploring kenotic christology by c stephen evans paperback. Kenotic theologians address this problem by arguing that christ emptied himself of his divine attributes or prerogatives in order to. What we do know is that, against those who would espouse a kenotic christology, the son did not give up any of the attributes that are essential to deity in the incarnation. Its literary bearing by michael lieb after william b. Indeed, much of the weird theology that surrounds the socalled faith movement is based on a kenotic understanding of the incarnation, combined with a newagelike leap of logic that says that since jesus left his powers and attributes behind and lived as a mere man, we bornagain believers are. As i will argue, johnsons teaching about living a life of miraculous power is heretical precisely because it misrepresents what the bible says about the father, son, and holy spirit. He was fully man, but he was also fully god in the truest sense of what it means to be god.
This might suggest that my terminology is eccentric, so if readers prefer, they. These attributes were omniscience, omnipresence, and omnipotence. This book contends that a type of kenotic christology is present in kierkegaards works, developed independently of the christologies of contemporary kenotic theologians. This, however, raises the question of how these two natures can coexist in the one, united person of christ without undermining the integrity of either nature. The kenotic trajectory of the church in donald mackinnon s. The selfemptying of god 3 recent years have witnessed a renaissance of interest in kenotic christologies among philosophers of religion in particular. While the term is found in a number of patristic writers and formed a key point of controversy.
This collection of essays, by a team of of christian philosophers, theologians, and biblical scholars, explores the viability of a kenotic account of the incarnation. My solutions to these problems constitute my defence of a strict kenotic account of the incarnation. By 1840, several theologians began to construct their own interpretation of kenosis. The second problem is posed by the exaltation, namely the resumption by jesus of normal divine powers after his life on earth. In christian theology, kenosis is the selfemptying of jesus own will and becoming entirely. According to kenotic theory, christ abandoned aspects of his omniscience, omnipresence, and omnipotence in order to humble himself and become a human being. This book addresses crucial issues that postmodern theory has raised for feminism and for feminist theology in particular. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for. Kenotic theologians address this problem by arguing that christ emptied himself of his divine attributes or prerogatives in order. Buy exploring kenotic christology book online at best prices in india on. The spirit of biblical leadership faith formation ministries.
A biblical and theological answer to the false doctrine of kenosis introduction an. When the kenosis theory concludes that jesus is or was less than god as. In particular, the chapter defends recent work by stephen davis and ronald feenstra, who hold that jesus may be. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Exploring kenotic christology is a theological volume which does exactly what it declares in the title.
Proponents of a kenotic ethic take this passage not primarily as paul putting forth a theory about god in this passage, but as using gods humility exhibited in the incarnation as a call for christians to be similarly subservient to others. Scottish kenoticists claimed the word retracted his divine attributes during the incarnation. Kenosis, then, the corresponding noun, has become a technical term for the humiliation of the son in the incarnation, but in recent years has acquired a still more technical sense, i. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for philosophical theology in general and the doctrine of the trinity in particular, and it concludes with essays that. This collection of essays, by a team of of christian philoso. Christ did this voluntarily so that he could function as a man in order to fulfill the work of redemption. The selfemptying of god individual contributors implicitly or explicitly adopt speci. We need a kenotic theory which makes kenosisoriginal to the being. Some essays test the theory by raising critical questions and arguing that traditional accounts of the incarnation can achieve the goals of kenotic theories as well. Instead, he manifested the form of god in the likeness of humanity. We use cookies to offer you a better experience, personalize content, tailor advertising, provide social media features, and better understand the use of our services. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for philosophical theology in general and the doctrine of the trinity in. One theory, which received widespread emphasis and acceptance in the late nineteenth century and whose influence is still felt today, is the socalled kenotic.
Some essays test the theory by raising critical questions and arguing that traditional accounts of the incarnation can achieve the goals of kenotic theories as well as kenotic theories can. Buy exploring kenotic christology book online at low. Oct 18, 2018 the classical view of the incarnation teaches that jesus maintained all of his divine attributes. The aim of kierkegaards christology is not to provide a rationally satisfying theory of the incarnation, but to highlight the existential challenge with which christ confronts each human being. Kierkegaards kenotic christology 9780199698639 by david r. Click download or read online button to get the kenotic trajectory of the church in donald mackinnon s theology book now. What christ became in the incarnation is what he shall remain eternally heb 2.
Packer argues that the scriptures clearly demonstrate that jesus was fully god. Exploring kenotic christology is a compilation of 12 essays edited by stephen evans. Jan 11, 2020 bill johnson of bethel church has made this selfemptying doctrine of jesus the very backbone of his teaching and ministry. Get it today with same day delivery, order pickup or drive up. The orthodox doctrine of the incarnation affirms that christ is both truly divine and truly human. In christianity, there exists a socalled kenotic doctrine kenosis. Its aim is to solve some of the supposed paradoxes arising from jesus having both a divine nature and a human nature. Aug 04, 2016 a brief history of the kenosis theory kenoticism, from the gk. Proponents of a kenotic ethic take this passage not primarily as paul putting forth a theory.
The biblical passage from which the theory of kenosis is derived is philippians 2. For that reason, i must use the word heresy to speak of bill johnsons book when heaven invades earth. According to the kenotic theory, when the son of god was incarnated as jesus of nazareth, he emptied himself of some of his divine attributes for example, omnipotence, omniscience, and omnipresence and lived for a period on earth within the limitations of human existence. The preexistent christ, a separate divine person, is the being who becomes incarnate, and was made man. Through a collection of thirteen essays by various authors this book takes on almost the full raft of issues surrounding kenotic christology. Several kenotic theories from kenosis or emptying have been propounded over. The incarnation of the son of god ligonier ministries. In the 19th century, liberal scholars propounded a doctrine called the kenotic theory of the incarnation, and you may have heard it, the idea being that when jesus came to this earth, he laid aside his divine attributes so that the godman at least touching his deity no longer had the divine attributes of omniscience, omnipotence, and all the. Ligonier ministries what we celebrate at christmas. In summation, thompson asserts that any nonkenotic theory devolves into paradox. This would imply a doing away with what jesus became in the incarnation after his. This might suggest that my terminology is eccentric, so. In the 19th century, liberal scholars propounded a doctrine called the kenotic theory of the incarnation, and you may have heard it, the idea being that when jesus came to this earth, he laid aside his divine attributes so that the godman at least touching his deity no longer had the divine attributes of omniscience, omnipotence, and all the rest. The act of incarnation is an elegant expression of what god can do that is.
Mar 18, 2014 exploring kenotic christology is a compilation of 12 essays edited by stephen evans. Kierkegaards kenotic christology oxford scholarship. The word kenosis kenosis has entered theological language from philippians 2. Martin describes various perspectives on the kenosis verse. Usually these interpretations were intended to make the miracle of the incarnation more reasonable or more acceptable to the scientific mind of that century. The kenotic kenosis doctrine is heresy in christianity, there exists a socalled kenotic doctrine kenosis. Within the more focused attempts to advocate the philosophical and theological validity of a kenotic theory of the incarnation in the. It reduces the whole mystery of the incarnation and redemption to empty the. What has come to be called kenotic theology attempts to understand the incarnation of the second person of the trinity in light of the kenosis of phillippians 2. Bill johnson of bethel church has made this selfemptying doctrine of jesus the very backbone of his teaching and ministry. These accounts agree that the second divine person, the word, remained divine at the incarnation.
The kenotic theory of christs incarnationdrawing from philippians 2articulates a doctrine of the incarnation in terms of christ emptying himself and becoming a servant. Others have sought to understand kenosis predominantly from a philosophical approach, with the two natures of christ as a starting point. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for philosophical theology in general and the doctrine of the trinity in particular, and it concludes with essays that examine the validity of the ideal of kenosis for women, and a challenge to traditional christology to take a kenotic theory seriously. The purpose of this paper is to compare two rival accounts of the christian doctrine of the incarnation, the classical and the kenotic, defending the latter. Oliver crisp, in his book divinity and humanity cambridge, 2007. Exploring kenotic christology by c stephen evans phd. One theory, which received widespread emphasis and acceptance in the late nineteenth century and whose influence is still felt today, is the so. The term kenosis comes from the greek word kenoo, translated emptied in chapter 2. The kenotic theory of the incarnation takes its name from the.
Packer argues that the scriptures clearly demonstrate that. Oakes, sj expounds balthasars theology of holy saturday, and sets balthasars contribution against the background of the. Dec 18, 2019 what we celebrate at christmas is not so much the birth of a baby, as important as that is, but whats so significant about the birth of that particular baby is that in this birth we have the incarnation of god himself. Considered with particular reference to its anglican forms and arguments. This book did much to popularize the concept of the divine kenosis. Nov 05, 20 kenotic christologies the middle of the nineteenth century saw the rise of kenotic christology. Exploring kenotic christology goodreads share book. Such an account is inspired by pauls lyrical claims in philippians 2. The doctrine argues that jesus gave up some of his divine characteristics when he was on earth in the flesh. A brief history of the kenosis theory the heidelblog. The kenotic theory, considered with particular reference to. What we celebrate at christmas ligonier ministries.
Pdf kenosis and the nature of the persons in the trinity. What we celebrate at christmas is not so much the birth of a baby, as important as that is, but whats so significant about the birth of that particular baby is that in this birth we have the incarnation of god himself. He believed that the unity of his person must be mathematical a. Finally there is the problem of how it was possible for jesus to be the same person as the preincarnate word. Postmodern critiques of metaphysics question whether feminism is ultimately foundationalist and essentialist, attributing an essential nature to woman and substituting a new metaphysical theory in place of the patriarchal foundationalism of western thought. The kenosis theory states that jesus gave up some of his divine attributes while he was a man here on earth.
This, however, raises the question of how these two natures can coexist in the one, united person. Kenotic theologians address this problem by arguing that christ emptied himself of his divine attributes or prerogatives in order to become a human being. From start to finish the goal of the book is to make a place for the kenotic view of christs incarnation alongside, or in replace of, the classical view. Thompson seeks to trace the various trajectories of nineteenthcentury and some later kenoticism.
1424 818 576 344 503 380 870 736 607 149 919 46 582 773 1469 738 1131 982 606 1265 940 703 672 1196 1406 1223 623